Female bullying creates higher job dissatisfaction for working men and women than sexual harassment.
With the current strong feminist movement, you'd think women would seek to promote other women in the workplace. However, research-based articles written as recently as 2013 show that women in high-level positions will actively work to keep women in lower-level positions from being promoted. It's called Queen Bee syndrome.
In fact, research shows that working women create toxic environments more often than working men do.
So who will stand up for women if women will not? Do we have to leave it to the men?
The Workplace Bullying Institute found that female bullies choose to harass female co-workers 68% of the time.
This bullying often presents itself as passive-aggressive conflict, which leads to power struggles and a toxic work environment, which in turn leads to decreased productivity and diminished profits for a business.
In the UK, it is estimated that about 18 million work days are lostbecause of workplace bullying.
These statistics are disappointing to say the least.
Part of the problem is ignorance about how and when women bully each other in the workplace.
Here are some ways women bully each other at work.
A woman bullies another woman by ...
-
giving her the silent treatment,
-
gossiping about her,
-
giving her constant non-constructive criticism,
-
ignoring her,
-
isolating her in social situations,
-
showing emotional apathy toward her,
-
excluding her from a group,
-
assigning her meaningless tasks,
-
demoting her with out first communicating, and
-
having hushed conversations with others when she is near.
Another part of the problem is not knowing how to stop female bullying.
Here are some tips for approaching a coworker you suspect is bullying another woman.
1. Empathize
Seek to understand where the woman is coming from by showing attentive listening. Once she seems satisfied with what she's told you, respond with understanding. Refrain from indulging the negativity by remaining as objective as possible.
Say things like, "I have been noticing that as well," or, "That would be stressful/frustrating."
To express true empathy, consider sharing a similar personal experience.
As you consider her perspective, ask yourself, "What may have made her feel she needed to do/say that?" and, "Has her life changed recently in a major way?" and, "What kind of stresses may she be dealing with?"
2. Distinguish fact from fiction
With continued empathy and an attitude of seeking to understand, try to distinguish the difference between the facts and the assumptions.
Helpful facts include the actual origin of conflict, the actual words and tone used in the conflict, the actual events leading up to the conflict and the actual events after the conflict. Draw a line between what happened and what was felt - known information and filler information.
Only ask a couple of essential questions so she does not feel bombarded or interrogated. Essential questions could include any of the following.
-
"What else could you have meant by ___?"
-
"Is this pressure coming from you or someone above you?"
-
"What could have changed that caused this to start happening?"
-
"Why would such and such come after you?"
-
"What does such and such have to gain by doing this?"
-
"I can see how that made you feel this way. Could they be unaware that it made you feel that way?"
-
"If I were to ask them, what do you think their side of the story would sound like?"
Of course, tailor these questions to match the context and the individual.
From the questions, seek to reveal an objective reality. Talk about what information is still needed to fully understand what is going on.
3. Promote conflict resolution instead of conflict
Help the woman coming to you for support feel empowered to resolve the conflict. The resolution could be an action she can do alone, or it may require collaboration.
Either way, brainstorm peaceful productive actions with her. Consider how the effects of the top three or four ideas will affect those involved.
If the solution requires collaboration, encourage her to speak to the person/people involved with an aim for resolution and understanding. Brainstorm with her what she could say and how and when she could say it.
If needed, express a willingness to help or suggest someone else who can.
If someone like a manager or supervisor is needed to help mediate the conversation, seek help from someone who is not emotionally involved in the situation.
4. Consider the big picture
Recognize that a basic human need is understanding and acceptance. Always remember there are often many ways to achieve the same objective. As you help her come up with a solution, promote understanding and acceptance of others.
You don't have to agree to understand. And you don't have to agree to respect a differing perspective. Accepting opposing or differing ideas is essential to growth at work and in the soul.
All employees want a positive work environment, even the ones who don't make it that way. All employees want to get a long with their coworkers, even if they talk poorly about them.
Women, assert yourselves.
Stand up for victims of bullying. Sit with, talk with and grow with coworkers. Avoid discrimination. Work to make your presence a place where all feel equally welcome.
Women, risk it.
With love and patience in your heart, handle workplace conflict head on as much as possible.
Success at work means doing your part to create peace.